Spain: The Right to Be Forgotten Does Not Apply to Google’s “Blogger” platform – Miguel Peguera

29 03 2015

BloggerIn a recently reported ruling, the Spanish National High Court held that Google is not responsible for the processing of personal data on blog hosted on Google’s owned Blogger, and therefore, that the so called “right to be forgotten” established by the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) in the Google Spain case does not extend to a blogging platform.

The ruling reverses a decision issued by the Spanish Data Protection Authority (DPA) which had ordered Google to remove personally identifiable information from a blog hosted on Blogger. The claimant was a Spanish citizen who found that when typing his name on Google Search, the results included a link to a blog with information about a crime he had committed many years ago. While the official criminal records had already been cancelled, the information was thus still findable on the internet.

On the one hand, the DPA ordered Google to remove the information from its search engine. This was upheld by the National High Court, albeit ordering more precisely that Google remove the link from the search results – thus applying the criteria set out by the CJEU in Google Spain.

On the other hand, the DPA considered Google, as the owner of the blogging platform, to be the “controller” of the processing. Interestingly, the DPA found that while Google was not liable for the content of the blog, as it was shielded by the hosting safe harbor, the DPA has the power to order Google to remove the information from the blog.

The National High Court reversed that and held that the responsible for the processing is not Google but the blog owner. It further held that the DPA cannot order Google to remove the content within a procedure for the protection of the data subject’s right to erasure and to object.

Arguably, under the rationale that the platform is not the controller of the processing, other user generated content sites such as YouTube or social networking sites might also fall outside the scope of the right to be forgotten.

This post originally appeared on the ISP Liability Blog and is reproduced with permission and thanks

A longer version of this post can be found in Spanish on the Responsabilidad En Internet blog


Actions

Information

2 responses

29 03 2015
Evan Harris

Is not the headline is misleading, and inconsistent with the text

Maybe it should say “the so-called ‘Right to Be Forgotten’ does not extend responsibility for the removal of personal data [beyond search engines] to platforms such as Google’s ‘Blogger’”

30 03 2015
Kaixing Dong

发自 Android 版 Yahoo 邮箱

发件人::”Inforrm’s Blog” 日期:2015年3月30日星期一 时间:0:59 主题::[New post] Spain: The Right to Be Forgotten Does Not Apply to Blogger – Miguel Peguera

INFORRM posted: “In a recently reported ruling, the Spanish National High Court held that Google is not responsible for the processing of personal data on blog hosted on Google’s owned Blogger, and therefore, that the so called “right to be forgotten” established by the C”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s




%d bloggers like this: