News: Tulisa “Sex Tape”, false privacy turns into true privacy

22 03 2012

Earlier this week we commented on an interim privacy injunction obtained by singer and X-factor judge Tulisa Contostavlos to restrain the publication of a purported “sex tape” on the Internet.  At that stage, relying on reports of earlier statements by her management, we reported the injunction as being in “false privacy“.  Tulisa has now posted a clip on You Tube (see below) to her 1.7 million followers on Twitter, to “set the record straight”. 

On her You Tube clip Tulisa accepts that she is the woman shown on the video.  She says she is “‘devastated and heartbroken”. She provides an explanation of some of the background and says that the video shows her and her ex-boyfriend, Justin Edwards, aka MC Ultra.   She accuses him of having posted the video online.

Justin Edwards has responded to this video . On his Twitter page today he said:

‘To find the truth both sides of the story should be heard b4 passing judgement #thatisall.’

There are news reports of the story in the “Independent“, “Daily Mail“, “Daily Telegraph” and the “Metro“.

In other words, it appears that the case was not one of “false privacy” – but rather “true privacy” – a video taken in a private place showing intimate activity involving the claimant.  On the information presently available, it is difficult to see how there could be any public interest in the continued availability of such a video.

It seems likely that  the privacy injunction was granted on Monday on the basis that the “sex tape” in question did, indeed, show the claimant.   As mentioned in our previous post, it can be expected that, in accordance with the modern practice, Mr Justice Tugendhat will shortly hand down a public judgment explaining the reasons why the injunction was granted.

This case is an interesting illustration of the use of social media to disclose private information and then to deal with the consequences of disclosure.  The consequence of the initial disclosure has been, as is often the case, that more private information has to be disclosed by the claimant.   It remains to be seen how much further the dispute will be played out in the courts.

About these ads

Actions

Information

8 responses

26 03 2012
Law and Media Round Up – 26 March 2012 « Inforrm's Blog

[...] law news this week was dominated by the Tulisa privacy injunction and the long-awaited judgment in Flood v Times Newspapers. Tulisa used a YouTube video, which has [...]

1 04 2012
Case Law: Tulisa Contostavlos v Michael Mendahun and others, “sex tape” privacy injunction continued « Inforrm's Blog

[...] background and accused her former boyfriend, Justin Edwards (aka MC Ultra) of leaking the tape (see our post of 22 March 2012). A public hearing took place on 26 March 2012 (see our post of 27 March 2012) and the order was [...]

7 04 2012
Inforrm – Easter Break and record page views « Inforrm's Blog

[...] News: Tulisa “Sex Tape”, false privacy turns into true privacy [...]

3 05 2012
Inforrm Blog – Happy One Million Hits « Inforrm's Blog

[...] News: Tulisa “Sex Tape”, false privacy turns into true privacy [...]

4 12 2012
Inforrm reaches 1,500 posts – the popular and the less visible « Inforrm's Blog

[...] News: Tulisa “Sex Tape”, false privacy turns into true privacy [...]

24 12 2012
Inforrm is taking a Winter Break « Inforrm's Blog

[...] News: Tulisa “Sex Tape”, false privacy turns into true privacy [...]

3 01 2013
Media and Law Review of the Year, 2012: Part 3, September to December – Judith Townend « Inforrm's Blog

[...] News: Tulisa “Sex Tape”, false privacy turns into true privacy [...]

22 01 2013
Inforrm Blog – Happy Third Birthday « Inforrm's Blog

[...] News: Tulisa “Sex Tape”, false privacy turns into true privacy [...]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s




Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 3,934 other followers

%d bloggers like this: